“Arrived at Dr. Tufts where I found a fine Wild Goose on the Spit and Cranberries in the Skillet for Dinner”
– John Adams, April 8, 1767
For the first of my colonial Thanksgiving recipes, I’m starting with the basics.
Even I, a former picky eater, would have to agree that no Thanksgiving is complete without cranberry sauce. The modern variety is often mixed up with citrus peel and a variety of other ingredients that might not have been readily available in colonial era New England.
When I saw a version of this recipe online, I knew I had to try it. Thank goodness for good instincts, because it’s great. Simple enough to make over a campfire, I’d wager, this recipe is about as basic as it gets, but no less delicious for all that. The finished cranberries retain enough of their structure to be more easily added to a fork than modern sauce. Especially if one’s fork only has two or three tines, as many colonial forks did. The brandy taste is there, but because it cooked off, it’s mostly the tasty flavors left, rather than the alcohol. Just sweet enough, with the tartness of the berries shining through, it’s a great and easy addition to a holiday table.
(Sidenote: My mother’s family grew up calling cranberry sauce, “plutz”. Anyone else heard of that?)
Skillet Cranberries Recipe
Serves 4-6, so at least double for a large group
Ingredients:
- 1 pound fresh cranberries
- 2 cups turbinado or other raw sugar
- ¼ cup brandy or rum
Spread the cranberries in the bottom of a skillet. Sprinkle the sugar over them and place in an oven set to about 275F for about an hour, or until the berries are very soft. Remove from the oven and carefully pour in the brandy or rum to deglaze the pan, careful of hot spatters. Stir gently if needed to unstick any berries from the bottom of the skillet. You can either return the skillet to the oven or cook on the stovetop until the alcohol evaporates.
Can be made several days ahead of time, and kept in the fridge. Bring to room temperature before serving.
Any suggestions for a no-alcohol version?
There is “Imitation Rum Extract”, but I looked it up before posting this, and found that it’s got 29% alcohol, almost as much as a spiced rum like Captain Morgan.
To be fair, 1/4 cup is almost exactly two shots worth of booze, for something that serves six people, and some of it does evaporate in the cooking process. So, it’s going to be a very small amount that gets into any particular person.
Not sure what could be done for an absolute-zero-alcohol version. Maybe molasses and water?
I make a version of this for thanksgiving in a saucepan. For a no-alcohol version just use 1/4 cup water and take advantage of our more ample spice cabinets instead. This is utterly divine with cinnamon, ginger, cloves, and allspice. Spice it as strong as you like it…to start with, I’d offer a tablespoon of pumpkin pie spice.
To add to the above comment, I use orange juice for my liquid, plus the spices. I have also made it with a sugar substitute so that my husband (who is diabetic) can eat it.
I just made this recipe today. I can’t wait to eat it tomorrow at Thanksgiving! The colors really pop! I used rum although it probably tastes better with brandy, but I am on a budget. The color just pops! If everyone likes it (or everyone that would eat a non-canned version of cranberry sauce) I may make it a tradition!
I made this this morning and everyone LOVED it (well, everyone who would try it anyway) the brandy lent a wonderful flavor, but I didn’t have raw sugar so I used 1 1/2 cups of granulated instead.
I made 3 using:
Hudson valley rye whiskey
Spiced Rum (Kraken)
and Applejack
figuring those would have been the most readily available spirits.
No leftovers – party for 20.
I’d score it a success.